
On Queer International Solidarity
LGBTQ Identity has not always existed. It developed specifically under capitalism. Just as the proletariat has not always existed, but sprang into existence with the development of capitalism and class antagonisms; LGBTQ identity has not always existed. Same-sex attraction has, but the ability to see yourself in other people, see yourself at a social scene for people like you, and the ability to organize politically under an identity of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, or Trans developed in the historical epoch of capitalism.
Modern LGBTQ Identity was shaped and fractured and shaped again by capitalism. First, those of us labeled as something besides cis or straight were all just “gay,” then “gay and lesbian,:” then “gay, lesbian, bi and trans.” And so on and so forth to today where we have a whole myriad of identities gathered under the rainbow banner of gender and sexual deviation from hetero-normative society. 1
In the ongoing context of worldwide violence being instigated and outright engaged in by the capitalist imperialist powers and the furthering of settler colonial projects around the world; the question about queer solidarity is brought up over and over. “Is it right?” to support these besieged nations that have been perceived as being abnormally backwards in their social treatment of queer people? Can’t we justify a military invasion to liberate the oppressed queer people in these “backwards” places? Do anecdotal examples of violence on LGBTQ people in these besieged states qualify enough reason to bomb schools, hospitals, and hundreds of thousands –if not millions– of men, women, and children?
To answer all of these questions quickly: No. Absolutely not.
To expand, international solidarity is inherently for the liberation of queer people. The liberation of all people, and this includes queer people, because (Surprise!) queer people are people, is directly correlated with the end of imperialism and the end of capitalism. Only in a socialist system where people are afforded their rights because they are workers can queer people truly find liberation.
Queer International Solidarity means calling for a decolonized and Free Palestine, from the river to the sea, for an end to sanctions in Venezuela & Cuba, for land back in America and all colonized places throughout the world, for an end of hostilities against Iran, for NATO and Ukraine to submit to Russia’s demands, for the withdrawal of American influences in South Korea.
First, we will examine how LGBTQ Identity came about under capitalism, and the contradictory nature of capitalism’s development of LGBTQ Identity and it’s simultaneous oppression of those living within that identity. Second, we will also spend some time talking about how the psychology of western nations is shaped by state and police sanctioned violence and oppression, and how this state sanctioned violence directly affects and shapes queer identity as it was historically developed. Third, we will examine common critiques made about the nations accused of moral backwardness by the powers committing genocide. The absolute hypocrisy of imperialist nations can be proven with a closer look at the claims made about these besieged states and a look at how the accuser has failed to account for their own violence against queer people. Lastly, we will present our deductions and the conclusion.
The Material Conditions That Formed LGBTQ Identity
The development of LGBTQ identity has been shaped by the capitalist system drawing all members of the household out of the family mode of production and into the capitalist mode of production. This is not a moral analysis about love and romance, but an objective analysis about how Patriarchy and Capitalism functioned.
In the past, when all of the family needed each of it’s parts to survive, the family mode of production ruled as the dominant economic mode of production in society. Patriarchal systems of property bestowed the wife and her children to the husband, as well as the property they lived on and everything else on that property. The husband would work outside the home to produce raw materials of all kinds: fresh milk from cattle, fresh produce from farming, wool from sheep & flax from gathering. The wife would then use all sorts of skills to transform those raw materials into something else.
The women of the poorer classes in city and country spent their entire lives within the four walls of the home. A woman knew nothing beyond the threshold of her own home, and in most cases had no wish to know anything. After all, in her own home, there was so much to do, and this work was most necessary and useful not only for the family itself but also for the state as a whole. The woman did everything that the modern working and peasant woman has to do, but besides this cooking, washing, cleaning and mending, she spun wool and linen, wove cloth and garments, knitted stockings, made lace, prepared – as far as her resources permitted – all sorts of pickles, jams and other preserves for winter, and manufactured, her own candles. It is difficult to make a complete list of all her duties…Even today you may still come across remote villages deep in the country, far from the railroads and the big rivers, where this mode of life has been preserved and where the mistress of the house is overburdened with all kinds of chores over which the working woman of the big cities and of the populous industrial regions has long ceased to worry.
Communism and the Family, Alexandra Kollontai, 19202
Because the family mode of production was the dominant form of economic organization, survival depended on it. This meant that anyone who wanted to form a gay identity could not. There simply was no place for gay men to meet up, cruising in parks before heading home to the wife was not a gay identity, and for a time this was just another example of moral hypocrisy. Many men engage in same sex activity and are decisively not gay, and both they and I would argue that their life and lifestyles are that of straight men who occasionally engage in gay sex.
And what hope would two women, wanting to form long term relationship, have of survival with no legal right to a job, or to own land, or a bank account. It simply wasn’t possible to build a relationship off a gay identity. And even if they could somehow figure out a way to survive without a hetero-normative family unit, where would these women go to socialize with others like them? Where could two men go to meet and socialize with others like them? No public gay scene existed. Incidents of couples like these are extremely rare expressions of humanity, but they are not representative of being able to say, “I am gay.”
Truthfully, people have always had all kinds of sex, in all kinds of numbers and configurations, but the simple act of sex between two men did not mean either man understood themselves to be part of a global community of people who recognized both themselves and this community. Many communities only allowed same-sex activity in forced, coerced, or otherwise similarly abusive or oppressive structures. These relationships were not based on love, but dominance, and to be the dominated was to be a lower type of person, if you were granted personhood at all.
It was with the development of capitalism that shattered this family mode of production. The capitalists, always greedy and always seeking more ways to squeeze even more surplus labor value from the proletariat, drives the wealth gap to the extreme. The husband can no longer provide for all the things necessary to survive. The capitalist, seeking more labor power, drew the woman into the workforce, allowed her to earn an income, to support her family. This new economic mode of production where the dominant driving force of production was wage labor caused families to form under different circumstanced.
With further discussion on the question of women’s liberation and the moral hypocrisy in bourgeois society reserved for another time, families were less and less being formed because women depended upon men. Of course families were being formed, but now for different reasons. Instead of coupling up by asking if it was necessary for survival, couples could form on the basis of other questions. Would this be a mutually beneficial relationship? Could this be a nurturing environment to raise a child in? Are we not just romantically, but sexually attracted to each other?
What if I consider myself a man (Don’t laugh!) and recognize I am sexually attracted to other men, could I form a relationship based on that? And if I wanted to, where would I meet other men who recognize this part of themselves? Then, later on, when oppressed by a political majority, to organize politically along the basis of this identity.
John D’Emilio’s 1983 essay, Capitalism and Gay Identity, he argues that it was the development of capitalism that allowed people to recognize themselves in society as gay or lesbian and then organize social spaces to foster a community on the basis of those identities. gay bars, lesbian literary societies.
As wage labor spread and production became socialized, then, it became possible to release sexuality from the ‘imperative’ to procreate. Ideologically, heterosexual expression came to be a means of establishing intimacy, promoting happiness, and experiencing pleasure. In divesting the household of its economic independence and fostering the separation of sexuality from procreation, capitalism has created conditions that allow some men and women to organize a personal life around their erotic/ emotional attraction to their own sex. It has made possible the formation of urban communities of lesbians and gay men and, more recently, of a politics based on sexual identity.
Capitalism and Gay Identity, John D’Emilio (1983)3
Capitalism, by separating the household from production and with the dominance of wage labor, made it possible for people to organize their personal lives around something other than survival. For the first time in history, it became possible for someone to say, “I am gay.” This didn’t just mean a sexual desire, but it meant part of a community of other gay people. This development happened unevenly, and brought about various contradictions that fractured the community under neoliberalism.
The development of gay identity and then it’s fracturing into an LGBTQ identity happened slowly. Over the course of the entire development of the rise and decline of industrialization. The development of an urban “middle class” (a temptingly comfy space within the working class where idealism and individualism thrives) also led to a dramatic increase in the number of publicly visible gay and lesbian people. However, due to compounding marginalization, the majority of this newly visible category of people were white gay and lesbian people. Before, the majority of the visible population of gay and lesbian people were largely people of color, with a large number of these people being gender divergent as well.
The surge in white gay and lesbian identity saw a dramatic rise in conservative attitude toward gender divergent and non-dominant based sexuality. (top & bottom culture) And a rise in assimilationist attitude. Simultaneously, compounding marginalizations also meant that white gay and lesbian people, especially those with assimilationist attitudes, would get easier access to higher paying jobs, and sometimes just access to “legitimate” or “legal” work in general. This meant that the LGBTQ black and brown communities were left even poorer than their white counterparts.
The decline of butch/femme rôle-playing among lesbians and of camp culture among gay men also contributed to a hardening of the gender boundaries that remain central to capitalist societies. The drag queens who, rebelling against the postwar tightening of gender discipline, had played a leading rôle in the 1969 Stonewall rebellion found that as social tolerance of lesbians and gays in general began to increase in the 1970s, social tolerance for gender-nonconformity in many lesbian/gay spaces decreased once more. In the earlier, smaller community of the immediate post-Stonewall years, nongender-conforming gay men and lesbians, less able or less inclined to hide, had been a higher proportion of the visible lesbian/gay milieu; as lesbian/gay communities expanded, the influx of more ‘normal seeming’ lesbians and gay men diluted the prominence of transgendered people. In addition, the less polarised gender-rôles in the broader culture, which had initially facilitated the emergence of lesbian/gay identities, now increasingly restricted the room available for more gender-polarised lesbian/gay identities. Although the temporary relaxation of gender-norms in the 1960s had created some space for playful gender-bending, full-fledged drag often seemed anomalous and even embarrassing in the context of the androgynous imagery that was in vogue in the early 1970s.
The Fracturing of LGBT Identities under Neoliberal Capitalism, Peter Drucker (2011)4
The emergence of gay identity was shaped, originally, by the already existing forms of oppression that exist under capitalism: class, race, and gender hierarchy. As gay and lesbian communities grew in visibility, they also grew more stratified. More divided. The contradictions that had made their emergence possible now produced new forms of exclusion, such as the marginalization of black and brown queer people, of trans and gender-nonconforming people, and of poor and working-class queer people of any number of identity that are not gay, lesbian, or straight.
The dual nature of this caused publicly visible LGBTQ cultural and community spaces, especially spaces where commerce can be done, such as gay bars, gay clubs, or where profit can be made selling commodities related to LGBT identity, to be shaped and patroned almost exclusively by this white gay and lesbian population. Due to how capitalists divide us into many categories of workers (by skin color, by sexuality, by gender, by nationality or national origin, by ability) so that they may pit us against each other for access to the means of survival, (housing, food, medicine, culture and social life) the compounding marginalizations of being a black trans woman from outside of the USA meant you were put into the most precarious position of survival.
To the extent that this general description is accurate, the following analogy can be useful in describing how Black women are marginalized in the interface between antidiscrimination law and race and gender hierarchies: Imagine a basement which contains all people who are disadvantaged on the basis of race, sex, class, sexual preference, age and/or physical ability. These people are stacked-feet standing on shoulders-with those on the bottom being disadvantaged by the full array of factors, up to the very top, where the heads of all those disadvantaged by a singular factor brush up against the ceiling. Their ceiling is actually the floor above which only those who are not disadvantaged in any way reside. In efforts to correct some aspects of domination, those above the ceiling admit from the basement only those who can say that “but for” the ceiling, they too would be in the upper room. A hatch is developed through which those placed immediately below can crawl. Yet this hatch is generally available only to those who-due to the singularity of their burden and their otherwise privileged position relative to those below-are in the position to crawl through. Those who are multiply-burdened are generally left below unless they can somehow pull themselves into the groups that are permitted to squeeze through the hatch.
Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex: A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination Doctrine, Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics, Kimberle Crenshaw (1989)5
Within the examination of the development of gay identity and how compounding marginalizations affect members of the LGBTQ community there are many contradictions that were pulled out by capitalism. That LGBTQ identity could only be developed under capitalism, but that it is simultaneously punished for existing under capitalism is a contradiction. The reason, of course, is for the bourgeoisie create a target for the working masses to blame for their suffering.
That LGBTQ identity was primarily black and gender divergent before the decline of Fordism, and with the rise of the working class became, essentially, gentrified & white washed and has now been shaped by this, typically wealthier, white population is also a contradiction. There has never been a need for the white gay and lesbian people who could assure their white straight gender-typical neighbors that they, “weren’t like those other queers,” to wield bricks against police officers
The people who originally conceived of gay rights and gay power were almost entirely black trans drag queens, and many of them sex workers. That the commercial & modern public space is almost entirely inaccessible to members of the black, brown, gender divergent parts of the community, after being the part to achieve the establishment of that commercial and public space is another contradiction.
All of these contradictions are symptoms of the growing crisis that capitalism itself presents. With the continued fracturing and oppression of LGBTQ identity, and the further increase in the wealth gap between the bourgeoisie and the proletariat, it becomes all the more imperative that we stand shoulder-to-shoulder with members of all oppressed people, regardless of our sexual or gender identity.
The development of LGBTQ identity happened alongside the development of the family under capitalism. It is no secret that the question of “Family” is of extreme significance to LGBTQ people. Families and their shapes, their connecting nature, and the reasons they form were all creatively developed by the different kinds of LGBTQ Families that formed. It was not just that we could meet in clubs and bars, but that we saw the Family Unit as something other than just a mother, father, and two & a half kids. Queer people developed found families, and hauses, and drag families, and queer housing, and gayborhoods. These were fundamentally different from the hetero-typical family for they were often formed by coming together, from a place of open mindedness and consideration. LGBTQ Identity and its development can be seen no less than creative expressions and developments of Human identity. LGBTQ and all sexual and gender divergent identities are nothing less than the evolution of our ability to understand ourselves.
We have discovered new ways to love and build relationships, connect with each other and form social units on the basis of mutual love and community. These are all wonderful additions to Human socialization. So the liberation of LGBTQ people should be understood as the liberation of all people because it allows people to continue to creatively develop how we form social relationships with each other. To evolve our understanding of ourselves.
Whether a Democrat or a Republican presides, both parties administer the same system on behalf of big business. As the trans struggle unfolds, it will become critical to develop an independent movement that can free itself from the grip of “lesser-of-two-evils” politics of waiting to get another Democrat in office. The truth is, you and I are the stuff that great leaders are made of. We don’t have to wait for a distinguished white man on a horse or a politician wealthy enough to win office in a multimillion dollar campaign to usher in justice and equality. The ranks of rebellions and revolutions that have shaped human history have been made up of people like you and me. That history lesson has been purposefully kept from us. Where is the great social movement in the streets that will help support and strengthen our demand for trans liberation? Will we see it in our lifetimes? No crystal ball exists to predict mass awakening. But laws of motion and development do exist: Repression breeds resistance. That’s the lesson of Stonewall.
Trans Liberation: Beyond Pink or Blue, Leslie Feinberg (1999)6
This call to solidarity by Leslie Feinberg, a revolutionary communist and trans activist who was one of the leaders who arose in the post-Stonewall Inn Riot era, is a reminder to us that we have a common enemy: the bourgeoisie. We are not the enemy of those who are, like us, oppressed by the bourgeoisie and then turned on us for a boon. These people have their psychology twisted and warped by media, literature, the hiring of scientists to “study” the “homosexual condition” and labeled us as “mentally ill.” I assure you, capitalists, my mental illness is but another product of the effects of capitalism, but it has nothing to do with my queerness.
Under capitalism the bourgeoisie restricts and punishes these developments of human socialization for their own profit, and at the expense of the whole of the working class, regardless of sexual or gender identity. So the queer proletariat must stand shoulder-to-shoulder with the non-queer proletariat against the bourgeoisie and smash their entire system, and build a new system where love and family are not questions that burden society with moral hypocrisy, but can continue to develop creatively. For the good of all people.
Now that we have gone over the material conditions that allowed the LGBTQ identity to emerge and develop, we will explore the effects of when the state took notice of the presence of LGBTQ people. The society that produced gay, lesbian, and trans people also sought to push it to the edges of society and further into precarity. Out of visibility. Through propaganda, moral panic, and state sanctioned violence the capitalist powers also shaped LGBTQ Identity and the psychology that people have surrounding it.
State Oppression & How it Shaped Queer Identity
The previous section identified the material conditions necessary for LGBTQ identity to emerge and this sections goal is to explain how the state’s regulation and propaganda also shaped LGBTQ identity. Official ideology, moral panic, institutional violence, and propaganda all helped to form the psychology and culture that surrounds LGBTQ identity. The psychology of queer individuals and communities is not incidental to state oppression but is produced by it, through mechanisms that operate at both the institutional and the psychological level.
The Dictatorship of the Bourgeoisie requires the State to act as it’s executive branch. (What a coincidence!) This State does not rule strictly on force, but also on the shaping of a society’s psychology. The careful trickery to make you think this is the only and best possible system to exist under. How lucky we are to have the threat of houselessness and hunger constantly looming!
The ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch the ruling ideas, i.e. the class which is the ruling material force of society, is at the same time its ruling intellectual force. The class which has the means of material production at its disposal, has control at the same time over the means of mental production, so that thereby, generally speaking, the ideas of those who lack the means of mental production are subject to it.
The German Ideology, Karl Marx7
This sounds like it’s a conspiracy. That every part of our society is secretly controlled by a small sect of the population, but it isn’t a conspiracy. This is a structural feature of class society. The bourgeoisie controls the economic system, and the entire means of production. This inevitably means they also own the media, the churches, the educational systems, the social programs, and all public venues for socializing. Libraries, museums, galleries, theaters. All owned by the bourgeoisie in a Capitalist system. All of these aspects of social life will develop and build the culture and so the social attitude of a given State. This means the Bourgeois State influences how people within given categories of society understand themselves and their place in that society.
John D’Emilio identified in his essay that LGBTQ identity was able to emerge with the separation of procreation from sexual activity, the dissolution of the family mode of production, and the creation of a gay political and commercial scene. In the classic contradictory nature of capitalism, it both provided the necessary conditions for thousands of people to identify as gay and immediately met those thousands of people with ideological resistance to their existence.
The capitalist turned every artisan, craftsman, and speaker into a wage-worker- into a proletariat. Karl Marx and Frederick Engels identified this in The Communist Manifesto.
The bourgeoisie has stripped of its halo every occupation hitherto honoured and looked up to with reverent awe. It has converted the physician, the lawyer, the priest, the poet, the man of science, into its paid wage labourers.
The bourgeoisie has torn away from the family its sentimental veil, and has reduced the family relation to a mere money relation.
The Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx & Frederick Engels8
The family as it once was, no longer existed, and new kinds of families were being formed. In response the bourgeoisie also purchases the labor of scientists and categorizes being gay or trans as a mental illness. The bourgeoisie purchases the labor of a priest who now tells his community about the evils of homosexuality. The scientific and religious institutions were developed by the bourgeoisie, a proletariat only owns their labor power until it is sold. What the bourgeoisie does with it once it is purchased, is up to them. These systems began to create a psychology around LGBTQ identity that lingers to this day.
The contradictory nature of visibility and the creation of a commerical scene means that LGBTQ people were not only targets of violence, but these locations that catered to LGBTQ people became hot spots for violence as well. The commercial spaces -like bars, clubs, and even down to neighborhoods where LGBTQ people were known to live in close proximity like the Castro or the Tenderloin- were owned by the capitalists. The contradiction meant that capitalists would both profit off of members of the LGBTQ community, and then make them vulnerable to and direct violence at those same people, in the places they own that cater to them.
Over time the violence and oppression began to reproduce similar ideas within the LGBTQ community as it sought to relieve itself from the violence and oppression it faced. For queer people this often takes the form of assimilationism, or the reproduction of heteronormative standards within the LGBTQ community. That if there are just enough “good” or “normal” gay people. No confused non-binaries or silly feminine gay boys. That if we are respectable, monogamist, consumers, and unidentifiable from a distance that we will be granted equality.
This is, of course, absurd.
There is no liberation within assimilation. This is, in fact, queer genocide. LGBTQ identity emerged under capitalism, it was shaped by state violence. In America, McCarthy accused gay people of being communist, and dragged members of the public before congress to accuse them of such. The FBI compiled and distributed lists identifying known homosexuals and other queer people to businesses. The effects of this was to push LGBTQ people further to the edges of precarity, then to hypocritically, blame us for our own conditions. These actions would disproportionately affect bipoc and gender divergent people who did not care or could not assimilate as easily as white cisgender gay and lesbian people could. Hunger is so motivating, and when told to hate yourself to gain access to food. How many of us would?
The internalization of bourgeois ideology produces what is known as moral hypocrisy that permeates all of bourgeois society. The bourgeois family is held up as the ideal while its actual functioning is one of exploitation. The woman is drawn out of the household to support her family, but at the same time becomes competition for her husband in the workforce. Even so she is pushed back into the heteronormative family model because it is held up as the ideal. There is no room for a queer family. The queer person who internalizes this ideology experiences shame or self-hatred, not because there is anything shameful about queer identity, but because the ruling ideas of society have labeled it as such. This shame is not a personal failing but a political condition, produced by the ideological infrastructure of the capitalist state.
Part of the struggle against class is the struggle against the psychological condition it creates in us. For queer people this means the struggle against internalized oppression as well. The task of LGBTQ liberation is not the overthrow of just class society, but also the smashing of the ideological domination as well. The liberation of society from this negative psychology will allow queer people and non-queer people to see each other as equals, instead of as allies. To recognize each other as each other. As workers fighting to free themselves from exploitation. The liberation of all people is, then, directly connected to the liberation of queer people. Who are, of course, part of the working class.
We have now identified how the Bourgeois State both provided the conditions for LGBTQ people to emerge, and also created the infrastructure and systems for its oppression. These systems of oppression are persistent to this day, and are seeing resurgence in thousands of anti-queer legislation being brought forward every year in state and national legislative committees. In the next section we will examine the hypocrisy of the Imperialist nations, and their violent quest for world domination, by comparing common claims of the targets of imperial violence with examples within the imperial core.
The Hypocrisy of Imperialist “Moral Backwardness” Accusations
When imperialist powers accuse besieged nations of “moral backwardness” regarding LGBTQ rights, they weaponize queer suffering that serves geopolitical ends while ignoring, and often perpetuating, incredible violence against queer people within their own borders. In anti-imperialist spaces we call this “Inventing Reality” as it is so coined by Michael Parenti. This is a specific type of propaganda that serves to justify military action and violence in a besieged state.
Let us examine that contradiction, and truly see the hypocrisy of the capitalist’s so-called “reasoning.” The imperialist nations will use the supposed status of LGBTQ people in these “backwards” nations as the justification for military intervention in these places. The supposed goal is to free these people. from the violent oppressive forces they might be facing internally. The actual execution of this is often with indiscriminate bombing campaigns or with a military blockade cutting the nation off from desperately needed resources. This would, of course, cause many people to die.
We find that the sanctions have inflicted, and increasingly inflict, very serious harm to human life and health, including an estimated more than 40,000 deaths from 2017–2018; and that these sanctions would fit the definition of collective punishment of the civilian population as described in both the Geneva and Hague international conventions, to which the US is a signatory. They are also illegal under international law and treaties which the US has signed, and would appear to violate US law as well.
Economic Sanctions as Collective Punishment: The Case of Venezuela By Mark Weisbrot and Jeffrey Sachs9
Now, if by common estimates we assume that 1 in 10 people are LGBTQ: would this not mean that 4,000 LGBTQ people were killed by the economic sanctions being levied against Venezuela by The United States of America? Is this not a contradictory way to seek liberation for LGBTQ people or for women? The targeted vulnerable populations, women and LGBTQ people, are killed by this act of saving them. And this is only one example of the hypocrisy of western states.
How many trans men and trans women are not just harassed, but violently attacked and murdered within the borders of America for simply existing? Rest in Power to Shyyell Diamond Sanchez-McCray, a black trans drag queen and activist who was murdered in Virginia.10 Rest in Power to Jayla McGee, who was murdered by her boyfriend at 19 years old, and afterwards was deadnamed and misgendered by the police.11 Rest in Power to every black queer person who’s entire existence has been a war against the racist, sexist, homophobic police of America.
How have we come to understand and characterize the LGBTQ Rights movement more than anything else? Historically, our civil rights movement can be characterized as queer people fighting back against cops. Imagine calling other foreign nations a danger for LGBTQ people, while failing to acknowledge the war we have had to fight against police and legislation here in the imperial core. What a convincing argument to make! “No where is safe for queers! Give it up!” Do you think we don’t know? Is this not why we fight?
The entire nature of the LGBTQ Civil Rights movement is a war between the queer victims of capitalism and police brutality and the police officers, themselves, as defenders of capital. Rarely have our historical events surrounding the freedom of LGBTQ people involved action less than a black trans woman and drag queen throwing a brick at a cop car. (Rest in power, Marsha P. Johnson).
And what happened to that civil rights leader? Marsha P. Johnson was the revolutionary who took the first action to fight back against the violent, racist, homophobic NYPD. Days after leading and celebrating the first Pride Parade in our communities history she was found murdered. The NYPD made two, (ONLY TWO I CANNOT STRESS THIS ENOUGH) short phone calls.
And closed the case. 12
In the nearly sixty years since the Stonewall Inn riots- for they were not a parade, it was not a march, it was a week of loud, angry, violent riots -we have gained only platitudes towards liberation. Queer people are still at a higher risk of houselessness, unemployment, and self-harm. Queer children are still removed from their homes for being caught in the closet. Queer people are still murdered for being caught outside alone.
And in Palestine, where a genocide is being carried out every single day, even in days under the banner of a “ceasefire” by the cruel colonial settler state of Israel. This fake state, created by white supremacists, claims to be protecting women and queer people from the sexist and homophobic nature of Palestinians. When a queer person advocates for freedom for Palestinians they get met with the same claim, every time.
“They would throw you off of a rooftop in Gaza.”
This claim cannot be a serious one. If you cared about people being thrown off of rooftops would you seriously recommend bombing all the rooftops out of existence a solution to this problem? Do you expect a people to evolve their social understanding of queer people from underneath the ruins of your tax-paid-for bombs?
Do not claim to care for the queer people you have condemned to a graveyard under the remnants of rooftops.13 The Democrats at best, in the United States, have offered “following the law” on Trans Rights.
“I believe we should follow the law, and it’s a law that Donald Trump followed.”
Kamala Harris, when asked about Trans Rights on the 2024 Campaign Trail.14
This is the promise of the Democratic Party of the USA. The practical solution to fighting conservatism in America is a platitude that defers to any transphobic law that is one the books, already. This statement, in it’s full context, defers to doctors and family decisions. Republicans also wish to defer trans issues to the private family life.
Who is the benefactor of all these ideas? Who benefits from the discrimination of trans people, and the virtue signaling of trans rights in foreign countries? Who benefits from the continued genocide in Palestine? Who benefits from the continued war on Iran?
The bourgeoisie do. The people never benefit. The masses of people lose in all these situations. At home we are fighting over the rights of people who are being bombed by our taxpayer money. In Palestine and Iran they do not worry for the rights of queer people they worry about the next American-Israeli Terrorist Attack.
The bourgeoisie benefit from our fracturing, the rich and powerful the billionaires and their agents benefit. They profit from our cultural civil war, peoples fighting to evolve conservative ideas into more progressive ones. They profit from the destruction of oil rich nations. They profit from this hypocritical dual struggle of elevating our own consciousness, which has not fully accepted queer people and women as fully equal peoples in all ways and the condemnation of the so-called “backwardness” of foreign countries.
Another example of our moral hypocrisy, women are supposedly victims of a cruel regime and need to be saved in Iran, while having high literacy rates and making the majority of all educated people and workers in STEM fields. 15
It is clear that the true villains of all people are not individual governments in places opposing violent imperialist intervention. The true villains of the world are those who profit from our disenfranchisement, those who profit from endless world war and internal political dis-cohesion: the bourgeoisie.
True liberation for queer people will not come from electing a President who is a woman, or a gay man. There’s no transitional identity that could make this easier for the American people to swallow, either. You cannot elect Pete Buttigieg, a man who is gay in a disgustingly straight way, and consider this a sign of liberation.
The people must band together and overthrow the bourgeoisie, wrest from their possession everything they hold above us and keep from us so we are enslaved to their rule. The land, the resources, food, shelter, hospitals. Their capital must be taken from them and distributed amongst all the people based on need. All people must band together, regardless of sex, gender, sexuality, or any other trait to work together to create an egalitarian world. Where the only people who are suppressed are those who forced us to fight each other for the scraps of survival.
This is the only way forward, not just for queer people, but for all people. Straight, gay, cis, trans, or absent of all these labels. Is Socialism. Only under a Socialist system that unites people based on their status as workers, not based on their identities, compounded or otherwise, can liberate all people.
It isn’t until all people are free under Socialism that any queer people can be free wherever they are. From every river, to every sea.
- The Fracturing of LGBT Identities under
Neoliberal Capitalism, Peter Drucker (2011): https://drive.proton.me/urls/MQYRJWKRFG#t7FaVjL1l3lG ↩︎ - Communism and the Family, Alexandra Kollontai (1920): https://www.marxists.org/archive/kollonta/1920/communism-family.htm ↩︎
- Capitalism and Gay Identity, John D’Emilio (1983): https://drive.proton.me/urls/FAQTS585XG#MsC0uppTVKJk ↩︎
- Drucker (2011) ↩︎
- Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex:
A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination
Doctrine, Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics,
Kimberle Crenshaw (1989): https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1052&context=uclf ↩︎ - Trans Liberation: Beyond Pink or Blue, Leslie Feinberg (1999): https://transreads.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/2021-12-29_61cca107e2f6b_leslie-feinberg-trans-liberation-beyond-pink-or-blue.pdf ↩︎
- The German Ideology, Karl Marx (1932): https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1845/german-ideology/ch01b.htm ↩︎
- The Communist Manifesto, Karl Marx & Frederick Engels (1848): https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1848/communist-manifesto/ch01.htm ↩︎
- Economic Sanctions as Collective Punishment: the Case for Venezuela, Jeffrey Sachs & Mark Weisbrot (2019): https://cepr.net/images/stories/reports/venezuela-sanctions-2019-04.pdf ↩︎
- Black Trans Activist and Drag Performer Shyyell Diamond Sanchez-McCray Killed in Virginia:https://www.them.us/story/black-trans-activist-and-drag-performer-shyyell-diamond-sanchez-mccray-killed-in-virginia ↩︎
- NBJC Mourns the Stolen Life of Jalya McGee: https://nbjc.org/nbjc-mourns-the-stolen-life-of-jayla-mcgee/ ↩︎
- The Cold Case of LGBTQ Pioneer Marsha P. Johnson (2017): https://www.hrc.org/news/the-cold-case-of-an-lgbtq-pioneer-marsha-p-johnson ↩︎
- Gaza: Destruction of buildings increases by 10% since Ceasefire: https://news.un.org/en/story/2026/08/1168138 ↩︎
- Kamala Harris statement on Trans Rights: https://19thnews.org/2024/10/harris-gender-affirming-care-incarcerated-people-fact-check/ ↩︎
- Checking claims about Iran’s female literacy, STEM graduate rates: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/iran-female-literacy-rate/ ↩︎